Should You Renew Your COE or Buy a New Car?
At October 2026 prices, renewing costs about $15,000 a year against about $19,000 for a new small car. When renewing wins, and when it does not.
Renewing is usually cheaper per year than buying new, provided the car is in good condition. At October 2026 prices, a five-year Category A renewal costs $64,358, while a comparable new small car costs about $192,000 before the dealer’s margin. Spread over the years each one lasts, that is about $15,000 a year for renewing, including the PARF rebate you give up, against about $19,000 a year for the new car. The renewal comes out ahead unless the old car needs more than about $4,000 a year in extra repairs, road tax and downtime.
What renewing costs today
| Category | PQP | 5-year renewal | 10-year renewal |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | S$129,883 | S$64,942 | S$129,883 |
| B | S$131,819 | S$65,910 | S$131,819 |
| C | S$91,814 | S$45,907 | S$91,814 |
| D | S$11,392 | S$5,696 | S$11,392 |
PQP is the average quota premium of the last three months with bidding. Category E vehicles renew at the PQP of their vehicle category.
A ten-year renewal costs the full PQP. A five-year renewal costs half, rounded up, and is final: the car must be scrapped or exported when it ends. See how the PQP is calculated.
What a new car costs today
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Open market value (OMV) | S$25,000 |
| Excise duty and GST | S$7,700 |
| Tiered ARF | S$27,000 |
| VES rebate or surcharge | S$0 |
| Registration fee | S$350 |
| COE (latest exercise) | S$130,100 |
| Basic cost | S$190,150 |
Before the dealer’s margin, insurance, number plates, road tax and OBU. Dealers’ selling prices are higher than this basic cost.
This is a typical small Category A car with a $25,000 OMV. Add the dealer’s margin, which LTA’s monthly car cost list puts at about $18,000 to $40,000 for small and mass-market models.
The yearly comparison
Take a 1.6-litre car registered in 2016 that paid $20,000 ARF. Deregistered at its ten-year expiry, it would return a PARF rebate of 50% of that ARF, $10,000. Renewing gives that up, because a renewed car has no PARF entitlement.
- Renew for five years: $64,358 for the COE plus the $10,000 PARF given up, so $74,358, or about $14,900 a year.
- Buy new and keep ten years: $192,054, less a 5% PARF rebate of $1,350 at year ten, so $190,704, or about $19,100 a year, before the dealer’s margin.
The gap of about $4,200 a year is what the older car must not exceed in extra costs. On the same car, those extras are:
- Road tax: a surcharge of 10% in year eleven rising to 50% from year fifteen. For a 1.6-litre car that is about $74 to $372 a year on top of the base $743.
- Inspections: every year once a car is over ten years old, instead of every two years.
- Repairs and downtime: the variable that decides most cases. Get a workshop’s written estimate for the next five years before paying the PQP.
Use the renew or scrap calculator with your own car’s PARF, PQP and repair estimate.
When renewing is the better choice
| Situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Car is sound, low mileage, and you need it for five more years | Renew for five years |
| Car is sound and you may keep it beyond five years | Renew for ten years; you can still deregister early and get the unused COE back |
| Workshop expects major repairs (gearbox, hybrid battery, air-con) | Replace, unless the repair is far below the yearly gap |
| Large PARF rebate at stake, for example a continental car | Compare carefully: giving up $30,000 of PARF changes the answer |
| Not enough cash for either | Deregister and price going car-free |
What other owners choose
LTA publishes monthly COE renewals by term. For cars, five-year renewals overtook ten-year renewals again in 2026: 7,730 five-year against 6,977 ten-year from January to July. In 2021, it was 2,912 five-year against 8,393 ten-year.
Chart unavailable. The values remain available in the data table.
View data as table
| Year | 5-year renewals | 10-year renewals | 5-year share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 7,900 | 2,019 | 79.6% |
| 2016 | 22,472 | 7,059 | 76.1% |
| 2017 | 21,747 | 9,341 | 70.0% |
| 2018 | 21,674 | 15,440 | 58.4% |
| 2019 | 20,095 | 21,682 | 48.1% |
| 2020 | 7,841 | 12,230 | 39.1% |
| 2021 | 2,912 | 8,393 | 25.8% |
| 2022 | 1,343 | 3,346 | 28.6% |
| 2023 | 1,484 | 2,919 | 33.7% |
| 2024 | 4,074 | 4,991 | 44.9% |
| 2025 | 6,680 | 7,267 | 47.9% |
| 2026 | 9,587 | 8,304 | 53.6% |
When to pay
Renew in the month your COE expires. Renewing earlier uses the previous month’s PQP, but you forfeit the unused part of the old COE. You can also renew up to one month after expiry, at the expiry month’s PQP plus a late fee of $50 to $250 depending on engine size, but the car cannot be driven until you do. After that month, the car must be disposed of.
LTA publishes the next month’s PQP in advance, so you can see whether renewing in the expiry month costs more or less than the month before.
The Budget 2026 PARF change and this decision
Cars with COEs from the second February 2026 exercise onwards get only 5% of their ARF back at ten years, instead of 50%. For those cars, renewing at year ten will give up very little PARF, which makes renewal comparatively cheaper. It does not change the rebate of a car registered before then. See PARF before and after the change.
Sources
Reviewed 25 October 2026. Costs are COEkaki’s calculations from LTA’s rules and the October 2026 COE results. Renewal counts are from LTA’s monthly COE revalidation data, which runs to July 2026.
- OneMotoring: COE renewal, timing and late-renewal fees
- OneMotoring: PARF and COE rebates
- OneMotoring: vehicle inspections
- OneMotoring: road tax
Compare an equal holding period
The renewal comparison now places five-year renewal, ten-year renewal, replacement and going carless over one selected period. A five-year term is unavailable beyond its expiry; the tool does not invent another renewal or transport arrangement for later years.
Chart unavailable. The values remain available in the data table.
View data as table
| Scenario | Initial renewal payment | Renewal entitlement consumed | Unused renewed COE estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | S$50,000 | S$30,000 | S$20,000 |
| 10 years | S$100,000 | S$30,000 | S$70,000 |
For illustration, a S$100,000 full PQP means a S$50,000 five-year payment. After a three-year holding period, simple proportional estimates of unused renewed COE are S$20,000 and S$70,000 respectively. Both consume S$30,000 of renewal entitlement. The larger upfront payment buys flexibility; it does not by itself prove a lower cost.
These estimates exclude financing, repairs and body value. An actual deregistration rebate must be confirmed with LTA. A five-year car renewal cannot be renewed again. Claims about new cleaner-energy registrations from 2030 should not be treated as a blanket prohibition on renewing every existing petrol car.
Keep the PARF you forgo visible. If the disposal alternatives already deduct the current PARF and COE proceeds, do not add the same lost PARF again to renewal. Compare lender settlement amounts, insurance availability and written repair estimates before choosing.
For timing, use the early-renewal comparison. For payment steps, see the renewal and financing guide.