Renew vs Scrap Calculator
Compare renewal, replacement and going carless using your own cost assumptions.
Tax and loan rules last updated 13 Oct 2026. Sources are listed under How this calculator works.
Current Vehicle
This comparison covers cars aged up to 10 years on their original COE. Already renewed COEs need their current term and expiry date to estimate unused rebates.
For COE-exempt cars, use registration dates: before 15 February 2023, 15 February 2023–12 February 2026, or from 13 February 2026. Renewed COE cars are not PARF eligible.
Automatic prefill is an estimate. Confirm the official payable PQP for your renewal month; replacing the amount keeps your scenario.
Running costs and repairs
The extra repair allowance is added once. Keep it separate from the annual maintenance budget.
Replacement, finance and resale assumptions
Starting quote: latest Category A premium plus taxes on a S$25,000 OMV. Replace it with your own quote.
Same-period cost comparison
All options use the same holding period. A five-year renewal is unavailable beyond year five; no second renewal is invented.
- Renew 5 Years
- S$117,834
- Renew 10 Years
- S$117,834
- Replace the car
- S$220,150
- Go carless
- S$10,000
Disposal proceeds available now
PARF is forgone when renewing. Disposal proceeds reduce the replacement and carless options once; do not add the forgone PARF to renewal again.
Unused renewed COE is estimated proportionately at the end of the holding period. The replacement resale input includes its rebates. Financing inputs include interest and fees, not loan principal. Confirm early-settlement costs with the lender.
Renewal and replacement scenarios
Chart unavailable. The values remain available in the data table.
View data as table
| Scenario | Total economic cost |
|---|---|
| Renew 5 Years | S$117,834 |
| Renew 10 Years | S$117,834 |
| Replace the car | S$220,150 |
| Go carless | S$10,000 |
View data as table
| Scenario | Initial outlay after current disposal | Running costs | Financing costs | End disposal proceeds | Total economic cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Renew 5 Years | S$66,334 | S$51,500 | S$0 | S$0 | S$117,834 |
| Renew 10 Years | S$132,668 | S$51,500 | S$0 | S$66,334 | S$117,834 |
| Replace the car | S$170,150 | S$50,000 | S$0 | S$0 | S$220,150 |
| Go carless | S$-20,000 | S$30,000 | S$0 | S$0 | S$10,000 |
The renewal totals also include the one-off repair allowance. Negative net cost means disposal assumptions exceed the entered spending, not free transport. No discounting, inflation or future PQP is modelled.
Saved scenarios
Keep up to 3 scenarios in this browser. Load one to restore its inputs.
Browser storage is unavailable. Your saved scenarios were not changed.
How this calculator works
Compare the same holding period across renewal, replacement and going carless. Renewal uses the payable PQP and deducts estimated unused renewed COE at disposal. The replacement uses a final quote and a total resale assumption. Both disposal alternatives deduct the current car proceeds once.
Enter separate interest and fees for each financing arrangement over the holding period. Do not add loan principal again. Include age-adjusted road tax, maintenance and a separate one-off repair allowance. The five-year option is unavailable when ownership exceeds five years.
What this calculator does not capture
For cars on an original COE. Disposal, repair and financing values are your assumptions. Confirm actual rebates and lender settlement amounts. The model excludes inflation, discounting and future renewal beyond the selected term.
Frequently asked questions
- How much does it cost to renew a COE?
- The prevailing quota premium (PQP) for your car’s category: the full PQP for 10 years, or half, rounded up, for 5 years. The PQP is the average premium of the last three months with bidding.
- Is renewing cheaper than buying a new car?
- In cash, usually yes: you pay only the PQP instead of a new car’s COE plus the car and its taxes. But you give up the PARF rebate, road tax rises by up to 50% after 10 years, and the car must be inspected every year.
- When can I renew my COE?
- Before it expires, or up to one month after expiry with a late renewal fee. A late renewal uses the PQP of the month the COE expired.
- Can a 5-year COE be renewed again?
- No. A car renewed for 5 years must be scrapped or exported when that COE ends. A car renewed for 10 years can be renewed again.
- What do I get if I scrap instead?
- If the car is under 10 years old on its original COE, the PARF rebate plus a COE rebate for any unused months, and whatever a scrapyard or exporter pays for the car itself.